Who is responsible for an open protocol?
Sky’s permissionless design doesn’t necessarily put its governance participants beyond the reach of U.S. sanctions law, according to Ari B. Good, a partner at Cogent who advises crypto and financial-services firms on sanctions and anti-money laundering (AML) compliance.
The key question is how much control identifiable people retain over the protocol, he said. A 2024 federal appeals court decision involving Tornado Cash found that immutable smart contracts weren’t property the Treasury Department could block under the sanctions authority at issue.
Good said the analysis changes when developers or governance participants can upgrade contracts, pause functions or alter how a protocol operates.
“Calling your protocol ‘decentralized’ while retaining admin keys, collecting fees, and pushing upgrades does not make it decentralized in the eyes of sanctions law,” he said.
Sky governance can modify, migrate or halt the PSM through votes, according to governance records reviewed by Inca. A governance exception approved in 2024 also allows the facility to be halted without the usual delay, Inca added.
Good said knowledge of illicit activity matters, too. Developers or governance participants who know sanctioned actors are using a protocol and continue operating it without taking remedial steps could face greater legal exposure.
The Financial Action Task Force, the global standard-setter for anti-money laundering rules, said in a July report that DeFi arrangements can fall under its virtual-asset standards when a person or legal entity exercises “control or sufficient influence.”